| Division 3 | Sun 1 Nov 2015 | #2 | Jonathan Day (Barnsley 3) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 4) | 15-11, 15-10, 10-15, 8-15, 9-15 | | 2-3 |
| Division 3 | Sun 6 Dec 2015 | #2 | Jim Uttley (Barnsley 4) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 4) | 15-9, 15-11, 15-7 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Fri 11 Dec 2015 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 4) | V | Jack Cornell (Hallamshire 5) | 9-15, 6-15, 14-16 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Sun 13 Dec 2015 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 4) | V | Mark Pinkerton (Killamarsh) | 15-10, 15-13, 10-15, 8-15, 15-11 | | 3-2 |
| Division 3 | Sun 31 Jan 2016 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 4) | V | Dave Greenwood (Barnsley 4) | 15-6, 15-12, 15-13 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Mon 22 Feb 2016 | #2 | Matt Godson (C & R Health 1) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 4) | 15-3, 15-8, 15-8 | | 3-0 |
| Cup C | Sun 9 Oct 2016 | #4 | Joe Douglas (Barnsley 4) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 4) | 7-15, 8-15, 13-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Sun 23 Oct 2016 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Paul Gane (Woodfield 4) | 8-15, 11-15, 6-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Sun 6 Nov 2016 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Ian Peach (Doncaster 2) | 15-12, 15-13, 12-15, 11-15, 6-15 | | 2-3 |
| Division 4 | Sun 11 Dec 2016 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Ben Aldred (Abbeydale 4) | 15-9, 14-16, 14-16, 15-9, 15-6 | | 3-2 |
| Cup D | Sun 18 Dec 2016 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Ben Aldred (Abbeydale 4) | 15-9, 14-16, 14-16, 15-9, 15-6 | | 3-2 |
| Division 5 | Thu 16 Feb 2017 | #1 | Nathan Smith (Woodfield 6) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 6) | 11-15, 15-11, 11-15, 15-4, 15-4 | | 3-2 |
| Division 5 | Thu 9 Mar 2017 | #1 | Lee Rose (Stocksbridge) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 6) | 8-15, 3-15, 16-14, 15-11, 7-15 | | 2-3 |
| Cup D | Sun 2 Apr 2017 | #2 | Mike Swain (Woodfield 3) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 15-11, 15-11, 12-15, 15-10 | | 3-1 |
| Division 3 | Tue 3 Oct 2017 | #1 | Guy Tallentire (Fulwood 4) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 15-7, 15-7, 15-9 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Thu 19 Oct 2017 | #2 | Howard Baxter (Abbeydale 4) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 15-17, 10-15, 13-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Sun 5 Nov 2017 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Nathan Foster (Woodfield 5) | 8-15, 15-5, 7-15, 12-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 3 | Fri 10 Nov 2017 | #1 | Michael Hobbs (Fulwood 5) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 15-7, 12-15, 12-15, 15-8, 15-6 | | 3-2 |
| Division 2 | Sun 12 Nov 2017 | #4 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 4) | V | Howard Baxter (Abbeydale 2) | 15-11, 15-11, 15-12 | | 3-0 |
| Division 2 | Sun 19 Nov 2017 | #4 | Emily Westall (Hallamshire 3) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 4) | 7-15, 15-5, 15-8, 10-15, 15-8 | | 3-2 |
| Division 3 | Tue 21 Nov 2017 | #1 | Ian Freebourne (Doncaster 2) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 16-14, 13-15, 8-15, 15-10, 10-15 | | 2-3 |
| Racketball | Thu 30 Nov 2017 | #3 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire RB 2) | V | Matt Jones (Princes RB) | 10-12, 5-11, 9-11 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Sun 17 Dec 2017 | #1 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Lewis Doughty (Woodfield 4) | 5-15, 6-15, 3-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Sun 7 Jan 2018 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Howard Baxter (Abbeydale 4) | 15-5, 15-6, 15-11 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Sun 21 Jan 2018 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Lee Rose (Fulwood 4) | 15-9, 15-3, 15-12 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Fri 26 Jan 2018 | #1 | Mike Tomlinson (Woodfield 5) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 15-8, 15-5, 15-8 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Sun 11 Feb 2018 | #1 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Michael Hobbs (Fulwood 5) | 11-15, 5-15, 2-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Thu 15 Feb 2018 | #1 | Ross Bingham (Phoenix 1) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 15-10, 15-9, 15-8 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Sun 18 Feb 2018 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Gary Ward (Doncaster 2) | 15-17, 15-11, 15-12, 11-15, 6-15 | | 2-3 |
| Division 3 | Tue 27 Mar 2018 | #1 | Ben Thornton (Woodfield 4) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 15-12, 15-5, 15-9 | | 3-0 |
| Division 3 | Tue 17 Apr 2018 | #2 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Mark Pinkerton (Phoenix 1) | 15-9, 15-4, 12-15, 11-15, 14-16 | | 2-3 |
| Division 4 | Wed 26 Sep 2018 | #1 | James McClure (Sheffield Medics) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 9-15, 14-16, 3-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Sun 7 Oct 2018 | #1 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Adam Lattell (Woodfield 9) | 15-5, 15-7, 15-9 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Sun 21 Oct 2018 | #1 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Nick Paxman (Woodfield 8) | 15-7, 15-5, 15-7 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Sun 18 Nov 2018 | #1 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Matthew Williams (Abbeydale 4) | 15-10, 16-14, 15-6 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Fri 23 Nov 2018 | #1 | Dave Medlicott (Woodfield 7) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 15-12, 8-15, 5-15, 4-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 4 | Sun 2 Dec 2018 | #1 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Andy Hogg (Hallamshire 6) | 15-7, 12-15, 12-15, 15-8, 13-15 | | 2-3 |
| Division 4 | Fri 11 Jan 2019 | #1 | Mario Gal (Rotherham) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 5-15, 10-15, 19-17, 6-15 | | 1-3 |
| Division 4 | Sun 13 Jan 2019 | #1 | Andy Hogg (Hallamshire 6) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 15-11, 15-9, 15-6 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Thu 17 Jan 2019 | #1 | Dan Milner (Stocksbridge) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 4-15, 12-15, 15-17 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Fri 1 Feb 2019 | #3 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 4) | V | Steve Chandar (Woodfield 6) | 15-12, 15-12, 15-7 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Sun 10 Feb 2019 | #1 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Aaron Alcock (Stocksbridge) | 15-5, 15-10, 15-11 | | 3-0 |
| Division 4 | Fri 22 Feb 2019 | #1 | Nick Paxman (Woodfield 8) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 13-15, 14-16, 9-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Thu 28 Feb 2019 | #1 | Matthew Williams (Abbeydale 4) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | 12-15, 10-15, 12-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 3 | Sun 24 Mar 2019 | #3 | Nij Precious (Woodfield 5) | V | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 4) | 13-15, 10-15, 7-15 | | 0-3 |
| Division 4 | Sun 31 Mar 2019 | #1 | Rob Garbutt (Hallamshire 5) | V | Dave Medlicott (Woodfield 7) | 15-7, 15-9, 14-16, 15-7 | | 3-1 |
